Federal Judge Partly Grants Family First Life Bid to Enforce Injunction and Hold Rutstein in Contempt
A federal judge in the Southern District of Florida on September 25, 2024 granted in part Family First Life's motion to enforce a permanent injunction, hold David Rutstein in contempt and impose sanctions on him. The docket text does not set out the specific relief.
The company sued Rutstein, Mindy Rutstein and the National Association of Accredited Insurance Professionals on February 15, 2022, alleging a campaign of unlawful competition and disparagement. In August 2023 the court awarded the company $15,930,974.60 in damages against David Rutstein and the association, fined him $43,400 for 217 days of non-compliance with an earlier contempt order, and entered a permanent injunction barring the defendants from false statements about the company and from contacting or soliciting its agents. In September 2023 the court granted the company's fee motion, on a magistrate judge's recommendation of $838,236.
The company filed its enforcement motion on May 3, 2024. The court ordered supplemental briefing in May and in June asked the company to propose language amending the injunction to direct online platforms hosting the content to comply. The company filed its proposed order on July 2.
More Family First Life news
Family First Life Says It Hit $1 Billion in Issued-Paid Life Premium in a Single Year
UNCASVILLE, Conn. - November 12, 2026 Family First Life, the Connecticut-based insurance marketing organization founded by Shawn Meaike, says it has reached $1 billion in...
Family First Life Answers Connecticut Telemarketing Suit Filed by Wendell LaSan
Family First Life filed its answer on November 13, 2026 to a Telephone Consumer Protection Act suit brought by Wendell LaSan in the District of Connecticut (No. 3:26-cv-01297...
Texas Telemarketing Suit Against Family First Life Dismissed by Stipulation After April Settlement Notice
The parties in Bennett v. Family First Life filed a stipulation of dismissal on July 23, 2026, ending a Telephone Consumer Protection Act suit in the Western District of Texas...
Texas Telemarketing Suit Against Family First Life Ends in Judgment After Stipulated Dismissal
A federal court in the Eastern District of Texas entered judgment on July 8, 2026 closing a telemarketing suit against Family First Life, after the parties filed a stipulation of...
Michigan Telemarketing Suit Against Family First Life, United of Omaha and Others Dismissed With Prejudice After Settlement
A federal judge in the Eastern District of Michigan dismissed with prejudice on January 27, 2025 the telemarketing suit filed by Mark Dobronski, with each party bearing its own...