Second Circuit Revives Young Living Class Action Over Therapeutic-Grade Essential Oil Claims
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit on May 2, 2023 partially vacated dismissal of a putative consumer class action against Young Living Essential Oils, LC over marketing of essential oils as "therapeutic-grade" and related health-benefit claims. In MacNaughton v. Young Living Essential Oils, the court held that "therapeutic-grade" combined with specific health, physical and medicinal-effect representations is falsifiable and not automatically nonactionable puffery.
The panel vacated dismissal of New York General Business Law deceptive-practices claims and related unjust-enrichment claims and remanded for a fact-intensive inquiry into whether reasonable consumers were misled. It affirmed dismissal of express and implied warranty claims. The plaintiff alleged she paid a premium for oils marketed with those claims.
Young Living is a Utah-based multilevel marketer of essential oils; the case returns to the Southern District of New York for further proceedings on the revived claims.
More Young Living Essential Oils news
Young Living Served With California Prop 65 Notice Alleging Pulegone in Deep Relief Roll-On
BERKELEY, California - October 21, 2026 Young Living Essential Oils has been served with a California Proposition 65 notice alleging that its Deep Relief Essential Oil Roll-On...
Young Living Agrees to Up to 5 Million Dollar Class Settlement Over Essential-Oil Health Claims
A federal court granted preliminary approval on April 25, 2024 to a proposed class-action settlement under which Young Living Essential Oils agreed to pay up to 5 million dollars...
Young Living Settles Pyramid-Scheme Class Action as Plaintiffs Dismiss Case With Prejudice
Plaintiffs Lindsay Penhall, Sarah Maldonado and Tiffanie Runnels and Young Living Essential Oils, LC filed a stipulated motion on November 22, 2023 in the U.S. District Court for...
FDA Warns Young Living Over Disease Claims for Oils and CBD Products
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration issued a warning letter dated June 10, 2022, to Young Living Essential Oils Corporate, addressed to co-founder and chief executive Mary B....
Young Living Names Ben Riley Acting President
Young Living Essential Oils named Ben Riley acting president, effective March 7, 2022. He will direct internal operations to optimize performance and product delivery and report...